Tuesday, April 20, 2021

AFL All-Time Team

With Saturday’s sad passing of former Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs tight end Fred Arbanas, I couldn’t help but reminisce about the American Football League. It was a fun league with great players and great teams. So, in honor of Fred Arbanas’ wonderful football career, here’s a look at the AFL’s All-Time Team.

American Football League All-Time Team

First Team

Offense

Tight End
Fred Arbanas, Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs

Wide Receivers
Lance Alworth, San Diego Chargers
Don Maynard, New York Titans/Jets

Tackles
Ron Mix, Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers
Jim Tyrer, Kansas City Chiefs

Guards
Ed Budde, Kansas City Chiefs
Billy Shaw, Buffalo Bills

Center
Jim Otto, Oakland Raiders 

Quarterback 
Joe Namath, New York Jets

Halfbacks
Clem Daniels, Dallas Texans/Oakland Raiders 
Paul Lowe, San Diego Chargers/Kansas City Chiefs

Kicker
George Blanda, Houston Oilers/Oakland Raiders 

Defense

Defensive Ends
Jerry Mays, Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs
Gerry Philbin, New York Jets

Defensive Tackles
Houston Antwine, Boston Patriots
Tom Sestak, Buffalo Bills

Linebackers
Bobby Bell, Kansas City Chiefs
Nick Buoniconti, Boston Patriots/Miami Dolphins
George Webster, Houston Oilers

Cornerbacks
Willie Brown, Denver Broncos/Oakland Raiders 
Dave Grayson, Kansas City Chiefs/Oakland Raiders 

Safeties
Johnny Robinson, Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs
George Saimes, Buffalo Bills 

Punter
Jerrell Wilson, Kansas City Chiefs 

Coach
Weeb Ewbank

Second Team

Offense

Wide Receivers
Charley Hennigan, Houston Oilers
Art Powell, New York Titans/Oakland Raiders/Buffalo Bills

Tight End
Dave Kocourek, San Diego Chargers/Miami Dolphins/Oakland Raiders 

Tackles
Winston Hill, New York Jets
Stew Barber/Buffalo Bills

Guards
Bob Talamini, Houston Oilers/New York Jets 
Walt Sweeney, San Diego Chargers 

Center
Jon Morris, Boston Patriots 

Quarterback 
Len Dawson, Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs 

Fullbacks
Cookie Gilchrist, Buffalo Bills/Denver Broncos/Miami Dolphins
Abner Haynes, Kansas City Chiefs/Denver Broncos/Miami Dolphins/New York Jets

Kicker
Jim Turner, New York Jets

Defense

Defensive Ends
Ron McDole, Houston Oilers/Buffalo Bills 
Rich Jackson, Oakland Raiders/Denver Broncos 

Defensive Tackles
Buck Buchanan, Kansas City Chiefs 
Tom Keating, Buffalo Bills/Oakland Raiders 

Linebackers
Mike Stratton, Buffalo Bills
Larry Grantham, New York Titans/Jets
Dan Conners, Oakland Raiders 

Cornerbacks
George Byrd, Buffalo Bills
Miller Farr, Denver Broncos/San Diego Chargers/Houston Oilers

Safeties
Ken Graham, San Diego Chargers
Austin Gonsoulin, Denver Broncos

Punter
Bob Scarpitto, San Diego Chargers/Denver Broncos/Boston Patriots 

Coach
Sid Gillman, Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers

***

Hall of Famers
Joe Namath
Len Dawson
Lance Alworth
Don Maynard
Ron Mix
Winston Hill
Billy Shaw
Jim Otto
George Blanda
Buck Bucahnan
Bobby Bell
Nick Buoniconti
Willie Brown
Johnny Robinson
Weeb Ewbank
Sid Gillman

A curiosity of this AFL All-Time Team is that second-team defensive tackle Buck Buchanan is in the Pro Football Hall of Fame while first-team defensive tackles Houston Antwine and Tom Sestak aren’t. The mistake isn’t that Buchanan is in Canton. It’s that Antwine and Sestak aren’t. The same curiosity is found with the offensive tackles. Second-team tackle Winston Hill is in the Pro Football Hall of Fame and first-team tackle Jim Tyrer isn’t. Perhaps his post-career tragedy is keeping Tyrer out but his football career was that of an Hall of Famer. 

The AFL is under-represented in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Antwine, Sestak, and Tyrer should be inducted. So should Ed Budde, Walt Sweeney, Charley Hennigan, Larry Grantham, and a host of Bills defensive players. At the very least, they should have their Hall of Fame cases discussed. It too often feels like the selectors have shut the Canton doors on the players that played their football careers before 1970. The AFL should be celebrated and not forgotten. 

RIP Fred Arbanas. 

No comments:

Post a Comment