Thursday, December 22, 2016

Throwback Thursday: What They Were

I find it interesting to look back at the high school star rankings of NFL players. Here are those rankings of the 2017 Pro Bowl players according to Scout Recruiting.

NFC Pro Bowl Roster

5 Star 4 Star 3 Star
Julio Jones Odell Beckham  Mike Evans
Tyron Smith Larry Fitzgerald Trent Williams
Greg Olsen Aaron Rodgers Zack Martin
Everson Griffen Ezekiel Elliott Brandon Scherff
Gerald McCoy Devonta Freeman Jordan Reed
Patrick Peterson Aaron Donald  Matt Ryan
HaHa Clinton-Dix Fletcher Cox Dak Prescott
Landon Collins Janoris Jenkins Vic Beasley
Harrison Smith Ryan Kerrigan
Luke Kuechly
Richard Sherman
2 Star No Star
Travis Fredrick Jason Peters
Bobby Wagner T.J. Lang
David Johnson
Mike Tolbert
Cliff Avril 
Michael Bennett
Thomas Davis
Cordarrelle Patterson  (5 star JuCo)

AFC Pro Bowl Roster

5 Star 4 Star 3 Star
A.J. Green Amari Cooper Travis Kelce
DeMarco Murray Taylor Lewan Geno Atkins
LeSean McCoy David DeCastro Jurrell Casey
JadeveonClowney Maurkice Pouncey Brian Orakpo
Eric Berry Derek Carr Marcus Peters
Tyreek Hill Ndamukong Suh
Joe Thomas Von Miller 
Don’t'a Hightower
C.J. Mosley
Reggie Nelson
2 Star No Star
T.Y. Hilton Antonio Brown
Marshal Yanda Donald Penn
Kelechi Osemele Tom Brady
Delanie Walker Ben Roethlisberger
Le'Veon Bell Kyle Juszcyzyk
Khalil Mack Cameron Wake
Aqib Talib Lorenzo Alexander
Casey Hayward
Chris Harris
Devin McCourty

I'm not so sure about that 4-star ranking for Aaron Rodgers. He was so lightly recruited that he quietly enrolled and played his first season of college football at Butte Community College. Cal head coach Jeff Tedford accidentally discovered him there. That path doesn't sound like one of a 4-star.

It's been documented more than enough times that very few saw the excellent quarterback that Tom Brady would become in the scrawny little fella that he once was. Still, Michigan gave him a scholarship. Cal wanted him. USC did too. That doesn't sound like a no-star quarterback. If anyone saw Brady's potential back in those days it was Mike Riley. As a USC assistant in the mid-1990s he recruited Brady. As the head coach with the San Diego Chargers in 2000 he wanted to draft that scrawny kid. Brady's no-star ranking probably has less to do with his ability at the time and more to do with the fact that his high school recruiting took place about 20 years ago. The star graders likely hadn't even dreamed up the star system yet.

If I was Baltimore Ravens fullback Kyle Juszcyzyk I'd still be spelling my name wrong. 

It's fun to look back and see what people thought of proven/star NFL players when those players were mere kids in high school. It shows that some players were great from the start and stayed great. It also shows that these star rankings that get so many people hot and bothered often don't mean a thing. More often than not the players that excel in the NFL are the players that want it the most, work the hardest, and end up in the right place at the right time.

No comments:

Post a Comment