It always starts with the quarterbacks. The Vikings apparently surprised many around the league by keeping four quarterbacks on the active roster.
Kyler Murray
J.J. McCarthy
Carson Wentz
Max Brosmer
In particular, many seemed surprised that J.J. McCarthy was still on the roster. I will never understand the peculiar coverage of McCarthy. I’ve seen a lot of strange converge of players in all my years of following the Vikings and the NFL but nothing approaches that of McCarthy. It feels personal. I’ve seen many top-10, or near top-10, quarterbacks have a rocky start to their career and receive more accepting coverage. There has been zero patience with McCarthy. I wish that he’d be given the opportunity to simply relax and breathe. Christian Ponder was given far more room to succeed or fail. Anyway, there are many things about the coverage of McCarthy, in particular, and the Vikings quarterbacks, in general, that are a mystery to me. The biggest might be how easily everyone seems to forget head coach Kevin O’Connell stressing the importance of putting together the strongest possible quarterback room. He said it at the end of last season. He repeated it at the start of the offseason. He said it again after the signing of Kyler Murray. Again, after the re-signing of Carson Wentz. O’Connell repeated the need for a strong quarterback room throughout the offseason. Even new general manager Nolan Teasley mentioned it soon after he was hired. You’d think that something mentioned so often might actually stick. Somehow, it didn’t. Goes to show that many simply hear what they want to hear. Those thirsty for drama over everything only heard that Murray was signed to replace McCarthy as QB1 and Wentz was signed to replace McCarthy on the roster. No matter how many times he stated it, no one seemed to hear O’Connelll stressing the need for three capable quarterbacks. For a team that had to play four and three quarterbacks in two of the last three seasons, it shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone that a team would want to have three quarterbacks that can lead a team to wins. Combining Murray, McCarthy, and Wentz does that. Why spend an offseason building that room only to rip it apart on cutdown day. McCarthy on the roster shouldn’t be a surprise. For me, having Max Brosmer on the roster is the surprise. He should have an easy path to the practice squad.
The tight ends.
I wasn’t too surprised that the Vikings kept six receivers. The surprise was that they kept six receivers and four tight ends.
T.J. Hockenson
Josh Oliver
Gavin Bartholomew
Ben Yurosek
If Gavin Bartholomew blocked like Ben Yurosek, maybe they keep three. If Ben Yurosek caught like Gavin Bartholomew, maybe they keep three. Or, maybe the Vikings really like the potential of both.
The offensive line.
The Vikings were able to keep an extra player at perhaps a couple of the above positions because there are only eight offensive linemen on the initial roster. Only Ryan Van Demark, Caleb Tiernan, and Joe Huber back up the five starters. And Tiernan is currently rehabbing an ankle injury. If the Vikings have a significant trade/free agent addition in mind, I believe that it’s to supplement the offensive line.
The defensive line.
I really like the six defensive linemen on the Vikings 53-man roster. Over recent weeks, several pundits had roster projections with one of the veterans added in the offseason instead of second-year Elijah Williams. I never understood those thoughts. As an undrafted rookie last season, I thought that he flashed enough and showed enough potential to be an impact player as soon as his second season. I thought his presence on the roster was certain.
The outside linebackers.
While I have offensive line as the position the Vikings might seriously address, most have outside linebacker. Perhaps they are right, as undrafted players currently back up starters Andrew Van Ginkel and Dallas Turner. That was the case even before Tyler Batty was lost for the season with a torn ACL. With the position versatility of linebackers Eric Wilson and Jake Golday and defensive lineman Tyrion Ingram-Dawkins, I believe that Brian Flores and the defensive coaches have things planned to support Van Ginkel and Turner.
The cornerbacks.
Congratulations Zemaiah Vaughn! I didn’t expect the Vikings to keep five corners.
The punter.
In the most thrilling position competition of Vikings training camp, undrafted rookie Brett Thorson’s potential topped Johnny Hekker’s experience and stability.
Now, we get to sit back and watch the Vikings spend the next two weeks tweaking the initial 53-man roster.