Many talking heads and fans have latched on to Rob Brzezinski as a serious candidate for the Vikings permanent GM job. Mark Wilf perhaps pushed those thoughts when he said that Brzezinski would be considered. I don’t see it. If Brzezinski truly wanted the Vikings general manager job, we would’ve heard about it by now. He’s been with the team since 1999. He probably would’ve been considered when Rick Spielman got the job. He definitely would’ve been considered when Kwesi Adofo-Mensah got the job. I believe that Brzezinski knows his strengths and where he’s needed. His strengths are with the salary cap and he’s very much needed there. He’s been brilliant. I don’t see him as the Vikings next general manager.
If Rob Brzezinski is #1 on the candidate list of talking heads and fans, current Denver Broncos general manager George Paton is #2. It’s a fairly lazy take as Paton left the Vikings to take the top personnel job with the Broncos. So, just because he has a past with the Vikings means that he’s returning despite being under contract with the Broncos. If current GMs are candidates, why not Howie Roseman or John Schneider or Eric DeCosta? The only way the Vikings can add Paton is by giving draft picks for him. There’s no way that’s happening.
Who are “legitimate” candidates to be the Vikings next general manager? I’m certain of one thing. Vikings next general manager will not be an “analytics guy.” The next Vikings general manager will come with a history, hopefully long history, of scouting and personnel experience. Here are some of my favorite potential candidates.
Chad Alexander - Chargers Assistant General Manager
John McKay - Rams Assistant General Manager
Mike Bradway - Chiefs Assistant General Manager
Will McClay - Cowboys VP of Player Personnel
George Kokinis - Ravens VP of Player Personnel
Ed Dobbs - Colts Assistant General Manager
Terrance Gray - Bills Assistant General Manager
Andy Weidl - Steelers Assistant General Manager
Ray Agnew - Lions Assistant General Manager
The Athletic’s Alec Lewis directed me to several more intriguing candidates:
Ryan Cowden - Patriots VP of Player Personnel
Jeff King - Bears Senior Director of Player Personnel
Reed Burckhardt - Broncos Assistant General Manager
Trey Brown - Bengals Assistant General Manager
Trent Kirchner - Seahawks VP of Player Personnel
Matt Berry - Seahawks VP of Player Acquisition
VP of Player Acquisition! Come on! What kind of title is that?
Anyway, that’s 15 candidates. That feels like a lot. The list in front of the Wilfs is probably longer. If I have to narrow the 15 to five, my top five, right now, probably looks like this.
Chad Alexander
Ed Dobbs
Ryan Cowden
Trey Brown
Trent Kirchner
In the rivalry of scouting vs analytics, I’ve always been, and always be, with the scouting side. I appreciate the inclusion of analytics into the process but I’ll never understand “scouting” from a spreadsheet. I look forward to the Vikings return to a “scouting” GM. I narrowed the candidate list to the above five for their scouting experience, the drafting of the teams that employed them, and a general feel or hunch.
I know that the right general manager for the Vikings is out there. I hope they find that general manager.