Offense | Player | Defense | Player | |
QB | Kirk Cousins | DE | Danielle Hunter | |
RB | Dalvin Cook | DT | Shamar Stephen | |
WR | Adam Thielen | DT | Michael Pierce | |
WR | Justin Jefferson | DE | Ifeadi Odenigbo | |
TE | Kyle Rudolph | OLB | Anthony Barr | |
TE | Irv Smith Jr. | ILB | Eric Kendricks | |
LT | Riley Reiff | CB | Mike Hughes | |
LG | Pat Elflein | CB | Jeff Gladney | |
C | Garrett Bradbury | CB | Holton Hill | |
RG | Dakota Dozier | S | Harrison Smith | |
RT | Brian O'Neill | S | Anthony Harris |
On offense, Rosenthal went with a second tight end rather than going with C.J. Ham at fullback or a third receiver. He isn't wrong as I'm pretty sure the Vikings will want to have Irv Smith Jr. on the field as much as possible. In his write-up, Rosenthal mentions Smith as a breakout candidate. He isn't wrong.
Ham will see the field plenty.
On defense, he projected the Vikings' nickel defense rather than their base. That's really no surprise as the Vikings are in nickel for about 2/3 of the snaps.
If the Vikings were forced to whip up a depth chart right now, I wouldn't be surprised if Rosenthal's projected starters were at the top of their respective positions. In that sense, he did a fine job, especially for a national writer. Come August, I'd be stunned if Pat Elflein is still the starting left guard and I'd be very surprised if Shamar Stephen is one of the starting defensive tackles.
My current projections for the Vikings' starters, using Rosenthal's offensive and defensive parameters, look something like this:
Offense | Player | Defense | Player | |
QB | Kirk Cousins | DE | Danielle Hunter | |
RB | Dalvin Cook | DT | Armon Watts | |
WR | Adam Thielen | DT | Michael Pierce | |
WR | Justin Jefferson | DE | Ifeadi Odenigbo | |
TE | Kyle Rudolph | OLB | Anthony Barr | |
TE | Irv Smith Jr. | ILB | Eric Kendricks | |
LT | Riley Reiff | CB | Mike Hughes | |
LG | ? | CB | Jeff Gladney | |
C | Garrett Bradbury | CB | Holton Hill | |
RG | Dru Samia | S | Harrison Smith | |
RT | Brian O'Neill | S | Anthony Harris |
On offense, left guard is so wide-open that I can't even project the starter. I suppose that I'd like to see second-round rookie Ezra Cleveland as the starting left tackle and Reiff moving to left guard. That probably puts the five best offensive linemen on the field and that's been the stated goal of the coaches. The wildcard for the left guard spot might be second-year Oli Udoh. That would allow Reiff to hold down the left tackle spot until Cleveland is truly ready for the NFL.
On defense, I really like Armon Watts. I think that he'll be on the field a lot. Whether that's as the starter at 3-technique or as a significant part of the tackle rotation, it's up to him. The other candidate to start next to Michael Pierce is fourth-round rookie James Lynch. If he can be the pass rusher in the NFL that he was in college, he could be the Day 1 starter for the Vikings.
This is a fun May topic. Nice job Mr. Rosenthal. It's rare for a national writer to come in and accurately comment on and tinker with the Vikings' roster.
No comments:
Post a Comment