Players enter the seemingly endless Seniors Pool 25 years after they last played and after their Hall of Fame merits have been debated for 20 years. It’s a frustrating deal because many of these players should’ve been inducted decades ago. With some voters refusing to acknowledge any players that played before their time covering football, it’s actually infuriating for anyone that care about the game’s history. Those posers as voters should refresh themselves on the Hall’s mission. “Honor the Greatest of the Game. Preserve its History. Promote its Values. Celebrate Excellence Together.”
Anyway, here are the 52 candidates that will now have their great careers debated by the Seniors Blue-Ribbon Committee.
Quarterbacks (5):
Ken Anderson
Charlie Conerly
Roman Gabriel
Jack Kemp
Don Meredith
Running Backs (6):
Ottis Anderson
Larry Brown
Roger Craig
Chuck Foreman
Cecil Isbell
Paul “Tank” Younger
Wide Receivers/Tight Ends (9):
Mark Clayton
Isaac Curtis
Lavvie Dilweg
Henry Ellard
Harold Jackson
Billy “White Shoes” Johnson
Stanley Morgan
Art Powell
Otis Taylor
Offensive Linemen (11):
Jay Hilgenberg
Chris Hinton
Joe Jacoby
Mike Kenn
Bob Kuechenberg
Marvin Powell
Dick Schafrath
Jerry Sisemore
Walt Sweeney
Jim Tyrer
Al Wistert
Defensive Linemen (4):
L.C. Greenwood
Ed “Too Tall” Jones
Jim Marshall
Harvey Martin
Linebackers (8):
Carl Banks
Maxie Baughan
Mike Curtis
Larry Grantham
Lee Roy Jordan
Clay Matthews Jr.
Matt Millen
Tommy Nobis
Defensive Backs (8):
Dick Anderson
Bobby Boyd
Pat Fischer
Lester Hayes
Albert Lewis
Eddie Meador
Lemar Parrish
Everson Walls
Special Teams (1):
Steve Tasker
This is a fine list. It’d be an even finer list if Green Bay Packers do-everything back Verne Lewellen was on it. He probably should’ve been inducted in one of the first dozen, or so, Classes. Seeing as he played from 1924-32, he’s waited as long as anyone. He’s waited too long. I’m also surprised that Detroit Lions offensive lineman Ox Emerson isn’t on this list. Despite those issues, it’s a fine list. There’s at least 20 that have a serious case to be among the Final 3. My Minnesota Vikings bias leads me to Chuck Foreman and Jim Marshall. It hurts but the historian in me puts those two just out of reach of the Final 3. The Pro Football Hall of Fame voters must finally do their jobs and put the following where they’ve long belonged.
Lavvie Dilweg
Al Wistert
Both were among the very best of their era. Both won multiple titles. Both should have busts in the Hall.
After Lavvie Dilweg and Al Wistert, it’s a tough choice but it’s probably Maxie Baughan.